Skip to main content

HVAC answers

Heat pump or AC and furnace in San Antonio?

They cool the same. The choice comes down to how you want to heat a house that needs heat for a few weeks a year.

Quick answer

Both work well in San Antonio. A heat pump is usually the better choice for an all-electric home, because it heats far more efficiently than electric resistance heat and San Antonio winters are mild enough for it to run efficiently nearly all season. If the house already has natural gas and a furnace in good condition, an air conditioner paired with that gas furnace is still a sound setup. The two cool identically. The difference is only in how they heat.

The difference in one paragraph

An air conditioner moves heat out of the house. A heat pump is an air conditioner that can also run backwards and move heat in. With an AC you need a separate source of heat, usually a gas furnace or electric heat strips. With a heat pump, the outdoor unit does both jobs, and heat strips sit in the air handler as backup.

Why the climate here favors heat pumps

A heat pump is at its best when it is cool outside but not bitterly cold. That describes most of a San Antonio winter: mild days, chilly nights, and freezes that arrive behind a cold front and leave within a day or two. In those conditions a heat pump runs in its efficient range almost all season.

The exception is the rare hard freeze, such as the February 2021 winter storm. In that kind of cold a standard heat pump leans heavily on its backup strips, which use a lot of electricity. For most households here that amounts to a few expensive days in a year.

When a heat pump is the better choice

  • The house is all-electric. The alternative is electric resistance heat, which is the most expensive way to heat. A heat pump is a clear improvement.
  • You are replacing the whole system anyway. A heat pump usually costs somewhat more than the same AC, and you get efficient heating for the difference.
  • There is no gas at the property, or you would rather not have combustion equipment in the house.

When AC and a gas furnace is the better choice

  • You already have gas service and a furnace in good shape. Replacing only the cooling side and keeping the furnace can be the lower-cost path.
  • You prefer hotter air from the vents. Furnace air is noticeably warmer than heat pump air. Some people care about this a lot.
  • Your electrical panel has no room for the circuit that backup heat strips need, and upgrading it would be costly.

Efficiency ratings to compare

Cooling efficiency is rated in SEER2 for both. Heat pump heating is rated in HSPF2. Under Department of Energy standards effective January 1, 2023, new split-system heat pumps must be at least 14.3 SEER2 and 7.5 HSPF2. Gas furnaces are rated by AFUE, the share of the fuel’s energy that ends up as heat in the house. More on the cooling side in SEER2 ratings in Texas.

What we would ask you

  • Does the house have natural gas or propane?
  • What is installed now, how old is it, and which part has failed?
  • Is the air handler or furnace in the attic, a closet, or a garage?
  • How much room is in the electrical panel?
  • How long do you plan to stay in the house?

Five minutes on those questions usually settles it. Call (210) 687-7376 for a free phone consultation. We install both. See heat pumps and AC installation.

Follow-up questions

Do heat pumps work when it drops below freezing?
Yes, with less output. A standard heat pump produces less heat as the outdoor temperature falls, so the electric heat strips in the air handler switch on to make up the difference. In San Antonio that happens on a small number of nights each winter.
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?
It depends on what you pay for electricity and for gas, and those rates change. In mild weather a heat pump delivers several units of heat for each unit of electricity it uses, which keeps it competitive with gas. Compared with electric resistance heat, a heat pump is clearly cheaper to run.
Does a heat pump cool as well as a regular air conditioner?
Yes. In cooling mode a heat pump is an air conditioner. Two systems with the same SEER2 rating and capacity cool the same, whether or not one of them can also heat.
Will a gas furnace keep working in a power outage?
No. A gas furnace needs electricity for its blower, igniter, and controls, so it stops in an outage just as a heat pump does. Neither system heats the house without power unless you have a generator sized for it.
What is a dual-fuel system?
A heat pump paired with a gas furnace in place of electric heat strips. The heat pump handles mild weather and the furnace takes over when it gets cold. It costs more to install than either option alone.

Not sure which fits your house?

Call Tom directly or send a request. Free phone consultation, no callout fee when we do the work, and we beat any verified quote by $10.

Call Tom Request service