Skip to main content

HVAC answers

Should I repair or replace my old AC?

How to decide on the facts of your system, not on a sales pitch.

Quick answer

Repair an AC when it is under about ten years old, the failed part is a common one such as a capacitor, contactor, or fan motor, and the system has otherwise been reliable. Lean toward replacing when the system is well past ten years old and has a failed compressor or a leaking coil, when it uses R-22 refrigerant and is leaking, or when it needs a major repair every summer. Age alone is not a reason to replace a system that works.

Start with what actually failed

“Your AC is 12 years old, you should replace it” is a sales line, not a diagnosis. The first question is which part failed and what it costs to fix.

Usually worth repairing at any age

  • Capacitors and contactors
  • Condenser fan motors and blower motors
  • Clogged drains and failed float switches
  • Thermostats and low-voltage wiring faults
  • A dirty coil that needs cleaning

Where replacement enters the conversation

  • A failed compressor on a system past its manufacturer warranty. It is the single most expensive part.
  • A leaking indoor or outdoor coil on an older system.
  • Any refrigerant leak on an R-22 system.
  • Several major parts failing within a couple of years.

The four things that decide it

1. Age and condition

ENERGY STAR suggests having a system evaluated for replacement once an air conditioner or heat pump is more than ten years old. That means take a look, not that you must replace it. A clean, well-kept 14-year-old system can be a better bet than a neglected 8-year-old one.

2. The refrigerant it uses

The data plate on the outdoor unit says R-22, R-410A, R-454B, or R-32. R-22 systems are the hard case because the refrigerant is no longer made. R-410A systems are still fully serviceable, though new equipment has moved on from it. See is R-410A being phased out.

3. Repair history

One repair in ten years is normal wear. A significant repair every summer is a pattern, and the money is better put toward a new system.

4. How well it has ever worked

If the system has never kept the house comfortable, has always left it humid, or was plainly the wrong size, a repair returns it to a state you weren’t happy with. Replacement is a chance to fix the sizing and the ductwork.

What replacement really gets you

A new system is more efficient than one from 15 years ago. Current federal minimums in Texas start at 14.3 SEER2 for most split systems, and older equipment was built to lower standards and has lost efficiency with age. In a climate where the AC runs for most of the year, that difference shows up on the electric bill. It still takes years of savings to cover the price of a new system, so lower bills alone are rarely the whole case for replacing equipment that works.

How to protect yourself

  • Ask which part failed and ask to see it.
  • Ask for the repair price in writing, even if the tech recommends replacement.
  • Be careful with any quote that comes with pressure to sign today.
  • Get a second opinion before any replacement.

One of our customers was told by a large company that he needed both a new coil and a new outdoor unit. Tom looked at it and showed him he didn’t. His account is on the reviews page. If you are holding a quote like that, call (210) 687-7376.

Follow-up questions

How long does an AC last in Texas?
The commonly quoted range for a central air conditioner is 10 to 15 years. Heavy run time in Texas pushes many systems toward the lower end, and a well-installed, well-maintained system can go past the upper end. Condition matters more than the date on the nameplate.
What is the $5,000 rule for AC repair?
It is a rule of thumb, not a standard: multiply the age of the system in years by the cost of the repair. If the result is over $5,000, replacement deserves a look. A $400 repair on a 9-year-old system comes to 3,600, so repair it. A $900 repair on a 14-year-old system comes to 12,600, so get a replacement price too. Treat it as a starting point for the conversation.
Do I have to replace my AC because it uses R-22?
No. It is legal to keep running and repairing an R-22 system. Under EPA rules, R-22 has not been produced or imported in the U.S. since January 1, 2020, so the refrigerant itself is scarce and expensive. An R-22 system that works and isn’t leaking can stay. One with a refrigerant leak is usually not worth recharging over and over.
Can I replace just the outdoor unit?
Sometimes, but usually not. The outdoor unit and the indoor coil are rated as a matched pair. Most new equipment uses R-454B or R-32, which can’t be used with a coil built for R-22 or R-410A. In most replacements the outdoor unit and the indoor coil or air handler are changed together.
I was told I need a whole new system. Should I get a second opinion?
Yes, always, for a purchase that size. TG AC & Heating offers a free phone consultation, and owner Tom Goodwin will tell you if he thinks a repair will do. If the system does need replacing and you have a verified written quote, we beat it by $10.

Want a second opinion?

Call Tom for a free phone consultation. If a repair will do, he’ll say so. If it won’t, we beat any verified written quote by $10.

Call Tom Request service